ICICI’s ECS doesn’t work and they trouble customers
By Vaibhav Aggarwal
Sep 26, 2008
Print    Email    RSS   

Customers of the largest private lender - ICICI Bank face problem with the Electronic Clearance Service (ECS) mandate.

ECS is a mode of electronic funds transfer from one bank account to another bank account using the services of a clearing house set up by Reserve Bank of India. This is normally for bulk transfers from one account to many accounts or vice-versa. Under this service the customer authorizes the bank to do transactions by filling a mandate form and depositing it with endorsement of the bank. Though the ECS deduction is automatic, the bank leaves the control of deduction in the customer's hands.

A collection agent from ICICI Bank disturbed Mr Prasad Rao, an employee of BHEL, on his daughter's birthday party. The agent had come to collect Rs 22,000 from Rao for an EMI of his home loan which had already been deducted from his account three days earlier.

The ECS deductions of the bank are becoming unpredictable day by day and thereby causing nuisance to the customers who have to face embarrassment and mental torture for the reason that are ‘unknown' to the bank itself.

Mr Parasuram, a lecturer with Osmania University said, "I had taken a two-wheeler loan from ICICI Bank in May 2008. A proper ECS deduction mandate was taken from me by the bank. Till now, only two ECS deductions were made from my account, though there have been sufficient funds."

He further explains that the problem continues when one gets a call from the bank about the dues. "From the very next day, the call centre/collection executives start pestering you for no mistake of yours. I tried explaining to them that there were funds in the account and that the problem was with the execution of mandate over which I have no control," he said.

The bank has problems in their execution and it is the customer who is tagged as a ‘defaulter' with a cheque-bounce fine of Rs 250 per month. People who bear the trouble caused by these collection agents land up paying a heavier price at the time of loan closure.

Mr Raja, a software engineer with Computer Associates said, "In my loan duration of 18 months for a bike, six times ECS deductions did not happen and I refused to pay the fine. But to get a no-objection certificate from the bank, I was forced to pay that with interest for one year."

All this leads to a bad credit history for a customer along with the torture that he faces for no reasons. This leaves no option with the customers but to approach a government body that hears and investigates on their complaints.

Mr Parasuram says, "It appears that there is no way out other than approaching the Banking Ombudsman as ICICI Bank did not respond to my complaint for the last five months."

However the Banking Ombudsman of Andhra Pradesh said, "We will look into all these complaints if somebody formally complains to us as per the prescribed procedure."

(Comments Posted : 2) Post Your Comments
1. I filled ECS mandate form for monthly deduction of loan installment but not even a single in deduction made through ESC, I pay cash or cheque on monthly basis.
Tripti (Posted: Jun 23, 2014)
2. This is a report COPIED royally from my report published in the Hindu Business Line without acknowledgement. This is VERY UNFAIR PRACTICE.
G Naga Sridhar (Posted: Sep 27, 2008)
Show All Comments
 Select a product:

 Select a product:

Complete Guide to the Home Loan Process in...
Repaying multiple loans – Which one...
Choose right repayment plan for home loans
Are you ready to file your taxes? Please...
Tax Planning for Working Women in India

PINJORE: CaℒL Giℛℒs In PiNjOrE 09915787550...
PINJORE: CaℒL Giℛℒ In PiNjOrE 09915787550...
how to gate my home loan certificate

Canara Bank earned a profit of 60%. Feb 6, 2015
New Branch of Laxmi Vilas bank at Vijayawada Jan 30, 2015
Home loan EMIs expected to drop down Jan 21, 2015
Corporation Bank received MSME banking excellence award 2014 Jan 19, 2015
Home loan rates set to fall, after reduction in repo rate Jan 16, 2015
News Archive